How to Shop Smart at Secondhand Stores

By Krystle Marks | Photography by Hillary Schave

Secondhand shopping offers a unique opportunity to experiment with trends and refine your personal style — without the high price tag. Here’s how to nail your next secondhand shopping trip like a pro.

TEST BOLD TRENDS

Secondhand stores are perfect for exploring styles you might hesitate to try at full price. Pieces like state- ment animal print jackets or wide-leg trousers let you experiment with fashion risks without the investment.

EMBRACE TIMELESS VINTAGE

Vintage is always in style, and when mixed with modern staples, it feels fresh. Look for high-quality vintage jackets, designer handbags or a classic band tee to add individuality and personality to your wardrobe.

INVEST IN LUXURIOUS FABRICS

Secondhand shopping lets you indulge in luxurious fabrics like silk, velvet and cashmere at a fraction of the price. These fabrics give outfits panache and are timeless, making them worthwhile investments for your wardrobe.

CHECK MULTIPLE SIZES

Sizing can vary by brand, so don’t hesitate to try on multiple sizes — particularly for pieces like denim, jackets or dresses. (This is especially true for vintage items, which often have different sizing than you’d normally wear.) You may find the perfect fit in a size you wouldn’t normally consider.

SELECT FLEXIBLE STATEMENT PIECES

Look for bold items that can still be styled in multiple ways. A printed skirt or eye-catching coat can be paired with basics to create versatile, statement- making outfits that work year-round.

PIECES THAT ARE WORTH SPLURGING ON

Some wardrobe staples are worth investing in — not only for their lasting quality, but also for their cost-per-wear value. These key pieces will step up your style and stand the test of time.

  • A High-Quality Leather Bag
    A premium leather bag ages beautifully, developing a unique patina that only improves with time. It’s a timeless investment that elevates any outfit.
  • A Tailored Blazer
    A well-fitted blazer is one of the most versatile pieces in your wardrobe. It can easily transition from casual to formal and is a staple for polished looks.
  • Premium Denim
    Investing in high-quality denim ensures a better fit and durability. Unlike cheaper alternatives, premium jeans maintain their shape and color, making them wardrobe essentials you’ll wear often.
  • A Trench Coat
    A classic trench coat is a spring essential. Stylish, practical and versatile, it’s perfect for layering and adds effortless sophistication to any outfit.
  • High-Quality Tees
    A great tee made from a soft, durable fabric like cotton is a must-have. It retains its shape and softness wash after wash, making it a go-to staple in your wardrobe for years to come.

STYLE MAVEN

Get to know Krystle Marks, owner of Krystle Marks Personal Styling.

Tell us about your business.

Krystle Marks Personal Styling helps clients build wardrobes that reflect their unique style, body
type, lifestyle and personality. From closet audits to wardrobe refreshes and shopping guidance, the goal is to make getting dressed effortless, fun and stress-free.

Some people think “it’s just clothes” — but you beg to differ.

What I love most about styling is seeing the moment someone puts on an outfit that truly reflects who they are. It’s not just about the clothes; it’s about helping people feel confident, empowered and excited to show up as their authentic selves. When you feel great in what you’re wearing, it shifts how you move through life, making everything feel a little more fun and effortless. That’s the most rewarding part for me.

Tell us about your best secondhand find.

A Michael Kors trench coat. For years, I struggled to find a trench that suited my frame, so when I stumbled upon this one, it felt like a true victory. Not only did it fit perfectly, but it’s also a timeless piece that I know will remain a staple in my wardrobe for years to come.

Where do you like to secondhand shop?

Style Encore, The Yada Project,  St. Vincent de Paul (on Williamson Street), Plato’s Closet, Recycled Sally’s (Baraboo) and The Next Generation (Stoughton).

Written By
More from BRAVA
Get a Free Headshot with this Fab Photographer
Written and Photographed by Kristin Dvorak Kate Longley’s necklace holds a dainty...
Read More
0 replies on “How to Shop Smart at Secondhand Stores”