Supper Club Your Way

By Kevin Revolinski | Photo by Hillary Schave

TORNADO CLUB STEAK HOUSE

The vibey wood dining room with white tablecloths here is perfect for intimate meals, while the lounge brings a cool factor most places lack, with curving booths, killer cocktails and a late-night menu that can be enjoyed at the bar. This spot brings a bit more flair to its steaks — such as the filet au poivre, an entree of local, grass-fed beef with a pepper- corn crust and topped with mushroom cognac cream.

Don’t miss the coquille Saint Jacques appetizer: scallops poached in white wine cream, served over mashed potatoes.

TOBY’S SUPPER CLUB

With a small-town fine-dining vibe and convivial atmosphere, Toby’s is famous for its fish fry (cod, perch and bluegill). Prices for surf-and-turf options here are a bit lower than other area supper clubs, too. Along with the traditional relish tray, Toby’s has cheesy hash browns and deep-fried butterfly shrimp. Don’t forget to order that old fashioned at the bar as you wait for your table.

THE DEL-BAR

Designed by a Frank Lloyd Wright protege, The Del-Bar’s Prairie Style building is distinct, beautiful and architecturally significant. Prime-aged steaks can be ordered with enhancers as simple as bone marrow butter or Oscar style, consisting of crabmeat, steamed asparagus and bearnaise sauce. Oysters are on the menu — but so are Sassy Cow cheese curds.

More from Kevin Revolinski
Your Guide to Getting Out on Madison’s Lakes
This is your guide to get out and enjoy our watery wonders.
Read More
0 replies on “Supper Club Your Way”